Andrea BELLITTO, Plaintiff, American Civil Rights Union, Plaintiff - Appellant, v. Brenda SNIPES, in Her Official Capacity as the Supervisor of Elections of Broward County, Florida, Defendant - Appellee, 1199SEIU United Healthcare Workers East, Intervenor Defendant - Appellee.

MARCUS, Circuit Judge: The National Voter Registration Act requires state election officials to make a reasonable effort to remove certain ineligible registrants from the voter rolls. The American Civil Rights Union ("ACRU") claims that Brenda Snipes, the former Broward County Supervisor of Elections, failed to satisfy her list-maintenance obligations. The district court, after a benc